Great idea for a thread.
I find that I agree with some and disagree with others.
First, not a fan of Alexis Texas, Lisa Anne or Jesse Jane. In fact, almost anything put out by DP doesn't really do it for me, I just don't find their scenes to be anything special at all.
I disagree on Jenna Haze, Phoenix Marie and Gianna Michaels, mostly because she seems to truly enjoy what she is doing and always seems to be having a blast in her scenes.
Others that don't really do it for me:
Bree Olson - never really saw the appeal in her
Gracie Glam
Kristina Rose
Nikki Benz
Perhaps as a counter to this thread, we should have a new thread regarding which porn stars are underrated in your opinion?