I'm having the same problem, not being able to upload a gif as an avatar. So is this info really outdated: "Note: The maximum size of your custom image is 180 by 180 pixels or 256.0 KB (whichever is smaller)."?
If so, then I'll probably not use an animated avatar, because it's hard to see clearly what's in there after a certain size/quality threshold.
Please note: Once payment is made you need to send a private message to wicked at the forum, stating your username and the email address you used to pay. If you do not do this your upgrade will be delayed, the upgrade will be done within 12 hrs.